• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

On the Side Sub Shop - Delicious, Generous Subs & More in Olean, NY

On the Side Sub Shop in Olean, NY, stands out for its generous portions, fresh ingredients, and bold flavors. From gigantic subs lauded by travelers to perfectly toasted buns and juicy chicken tenders tossed in medium sauce, every dish delivers satisfying, crave-worthy taste. Highlights include the savory cheesesteak with banana peppers and unforgettable breaded wings that keep customers coming back. Friendly service and a clean, welcoming atmosphere add to the experience, making it a top choice for locals and visitors alike. Whether grabbing a hearty Italian sub or a flavorful burger wrap, On the Side Sub Shop consistently impresses with quality and value.

On the Side Sub Shop at a glance

  • Address 241 N Union St, Olean, NY 14760, United States
  • Phone +1 716-372-3378
  • Restaurant type Sandwich shop , Meal delivery .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

On the Side Sub Shop: Reviews & Ratings

Senior
5

Im "Senior" from the TruTV Show, Full Throttle Saloon. Was traveling in from out of town.....WOW!!! Amazing sub. Size was gigantic and taste was amazing. Just look at the size. I've had Subs all over the world. This is one of the best ever.

Nicole Hughes
5

Had many differnt foods from this place like ,curly fries, chicken tenders tossed in medium sauce. A order of breaded wings and a cheese burger wrap and everything was very delicious. The prices are pretty fair with the quality you get. The tenders were so juicy and "tender" the medium sauce they tossed them in gave them just the perfect amount of slight spice. The fries were amazing warm. when they got cold they weren't to great but that is expected. The breaded wings were unforgettable and something i will be returning to get very soon. The cheeseburger wrap was very good, the only complaint i would have would be that the wrap had some of the oil dripping out the bottom. Definitely my new favorite place, returning today!

Sarah Marie Lynn
5

I’m disappointed in myself for frequently visiting Olean for work and never stopping in at this place . Service team is outstanding . I got the full cheese steak sub with banana peppers . Wow .. it was like Christmas in my mouth !! The full sub is definitely enough for two people but it was so good I crushed the whole thing myself ! I’m lame and typically eat my subs with a fork (eating the guts only and leaving the bread for trash). The bun was so perfectly toasted I ate the entire sub as is bread and all ! Parking available in the front and along the side lot . 3 large tables available inside if dining in . Best steak sub I’ve had all year ! Great price , great food , stellar service !

Jedi Fitness
5

My sons and I our visiting from out of town and we were looking for something good to eat. We got Italian subs and they are phenomenal!! I highly recommend this sub shop!

andrea sargent
5

Very clean. We had the hamburger wrap, turkey sub, roast beef sub, and french fries - everything was great. We ended up ordering a second helping of fries because they were so good. The two people working were very friendly and helpful. They cut up my turkey sandwich and put it on two plates for my 2 year old son and I to share, without me asking. We were just driving through Olean on our way back to Ohio, but will likely stop here again if we are in the neighborhood. Thanks again!

Parelli4life
5

Delicious food and friendly staff. My go-to place for the best sub in town!

Tanmay Kumar
5

Terrific turkey sub - in town to visit family, glad I popped in while other people were resting. Wonderful service and exactly what I was hoping for in a toasted turkey sub. Thanks!

Location

  • On the Side Sub Shop
    On the Side Sub Shop
    241 N Union St, Olean, NY 14760, United States Hotline: +1 716-372-3378

On the Side Sub Shop, nestled in the heart of Olean, NY, emerges as a true gem for sandwich lovers and casual diners alike. This sub shop has earned glowing praise from locals and visitors, making it a must-visit destination for anyone craving hearty, flavorful subs and comfort food with a twist. From the moment you step inside, the welcoming atmosphere and attentive service set the stage for a satisfying meal.

The stars here are undoubtedly the subs—gigantic in size and rich in taste. Senior, a notable personality from the TruTV show Full Throttle Saloon, calls their sandwiches “one of the best ever,” highlighting not just the generous portions but the impressive flavor combinations that make each bite memorable. Whether it’s the classic Italian sub, kissed by fresh ingredients and bold seasonings, or the full cheese steak sub loaded with perfectly toasted bread and zesty banana peppers, every sandwich promises depth and satisfaction.

But the culinary delights at On the Side Sub Shop extend beyond just subs. Their sides, like curly fries and breaded wings, receive equally enthusiastic praise. Juicy chicken tenders tossed in medium sauce strike an ideal balance of tender texture and mild spice, while the fries offer a warm, crispy complement that’s hard to resist. The breaded wings have become unforgettable favorites for many, beckoning return visits.

Service here isn’t an afterthought—it enhances the entire dining experience. Friendly, accommodating staff take the time to personalize orders, as one customer noted when staff thoughtfully divided her sandwich for sharing with a young child. This attention to detail and warm hospitality elevates what could be a simple meal into something special.

With fair pricing, generous portions, and a menu that caters to diverse tastes—whether you prefer a cheeseburger wrap or a classic roast beef sub—On the Side Sub Shop perfectly blends quality and comfort. The spot is also practical, offering convenient parking and ample seating for those who want to dine in and soak up the inviting ambiance.

In sum, On the Side Sub Shop stands out as an exceptional sub and comfort food destination. Its combination of massive, flavorful subs, delicious sides, and stellar service leaves a lasting impression. For anyone passing through Olean or looking for a reliable local eatery, this sub shop promises an experience that truly hits the spot.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards